So who represents the judge & jury that have decreed Scott Boras failed in these Arod negotiations? Sure, he didn’t look good, but he never really looks good. He just makes his clients gobs of money. The perception that Hank’s Yanks got the upper hand here and that team Arod/Boras are left with their tails between their legs are overlooking the basic fact that their walking away with some 300M. Indeed, there was no bidding war like Boras may (or may not) have anticipated. No, Arod did not get 350M. It was and will always be all posturing. Yeah, Hank Steinbrenner got off a few good lines (for posterity: him wondering aloud if Arod wants to go to the Hall of Fame as a Yankee or a Toledo Mud Hen; also rejecting negotiations with Arod by stating he obviously does not want to be a Yankee, and adding the ultimate barb: comparing Arod to Jeter – zing!).
I’m not quite cynical enough to think the plan the entire time was:
Step 1-- cheese off the Yanks;
Step 2 – play good cop/bad cop with them, making your client the good cop by reaching out to them while agent’s back is turned;
Step 3 – walk away with 300M.
But it’s probably not far off.
Announcing his opt out in the waning innings of the World Series – hilarious!
Suggesting he wants to explore other options because the Yanks are in transition – stop, you’re killing me!
Making nice by reaching out the Yanks instead of having the agent do this - okaaaaay
Supposedly making concessions, like the $21M the Yanks lose from the Texas subsidy- I’m listening
Working on a deal in the 275M range – wha?!
Adding a home run incentive clause – who’s writing this stuff?!
Is this really what the guy needs? Bonus money if he breaks the home run record? Pressure hoist upon him to hit home runs? Ohhhh dear, this is a mistake.
We’ll see how the dust settles on this deal, but so far, I much preferred the original idea for him to maintain his contract, and have the Yanks add four years to it @ $28M per. This would have cost the Yanks about 160M over seven years, methinks, while Arod would earn over 180M. But that wasn’t going to cut it…
It’s certainly wise from Arod’s perspective to stick with the team – to paraphrase Hank’s sentiment, Arod was in danger of being the greatest slugger who ever lived, yet would lack any team identification (many have appropriately said his HOF plaque would have a $ logo). This is a guy acutely aware of his legacy. But I think it’s the Yanks who were the ones really over a barrel here. The need to maintain a contending team as they head into the Disneyland version of Yankee Stadium (heretofore: YS2K9) has had them scampering.
Some people have a knack for PR missteps, and Arod fits that bill. But for all the bills he’ll be receiving, he’ll take that trade off. I’m glad the player is back. Aaron Boone would have gotten a nice opening day reception, but that love affair which weathered his mostly bad 2003 post-season would have soured fast. The Yanks are overpaying for Arod, and, like 2004, it doesn’t appear there were any other bidders. Hence: $25 yearbooks. Can the commissioner sponsor this deal so Barry Bonds can be erased from the record books? Maybe that’s why Hank Steinbrenner is so proud of himself.